Example of an outline Shown as informal and formal sentence
outline
Seeing one example of an outline is less useful than seeing several
ways of outlining the same content for the teacher who wants to
understand the strengths and limitations of each method of making
an outline.
Armed with that understanding, you'll be able to choose wisely
methodsnote the pluralof outlining best suited to your
teaching goals and your students' needs.
The four types of outlines are shown in the chart below.
On another page, I discuss and show examples of topic
outlines.
Sentence outlines present ideas
The difference between a topic outline and a sentence outline is
that the sentence outline is written in complete sentences. A sentence
is an idea.
Anything less than a sentence is not an idea.
Thus, a sentence outline shows the content and sequence of the
ideas the writer plans to present in the finished paper. Even an
sentence outline, however, may not make clear what thesis statement
the writer will attempt to prove using the outlined material.
Example of an informal sentence outline
The example of an outline on this page is drawn from a topic commonly
discussed in English language arts classes: Usage.
The sentence outline below uses an informal format. The main ideas
and subordinate ideas are shown simply by their alignment.
Notice that in an informal sentence outline each
point is
A full sentence rather than a sentence fragment
Lacking a number or letter to indicate the importance and placement
of the point in the outline sequence
Syntactically parallel to the points with which is logically
parallel
Example of a formal sentence outline
The formal sentence outline adds a standardized numbering
scheme to the informal sentence example of an outline shown
above. The numbering is just sequins; it does not improve the utility
of the outline.
Notice that in a formal sentence outline each
point is
A full sentence rather than a sentence fragment
Preceded by a number or letter to indicate the importance and
placement of the point in the outline sequence
Syntactically parallel to the points with which is logically
parallel
Did you notice that the addition of the formal numbering scheme
does not make the outline any clearer or more useful than the informal
topic outline? All the outlining conventions do is give students
one more set of unnecessary information to remember.
Thesis for the example outlines
Neither example of an outline on this page identifies what writer's
point is going to be. Here's the working thesis
for which each example of an outline was developed:
People are stereotyped by their oral language.
Do you think your students could write an essay from one of the
outlines on this page and prove that thesis if they didn't have
the thesis statement in front of them?
Perhaps they could, but why risk it?
Professional writers often print a copy of their thesis
statement and post it somewhere above their work area where
they can keep it in sight as they write.
Since your students' schedules may keep them from having a designated
place to write, train them to put their working thesis
at the top of the document in which they put their outline.
Plans beat outlines
Teach the writing skeleton as a way to plan an essay. Planning is normal.
Everybody makes plans. Outlining is a weird, English-teacher thing.
Linda Aragoni
Methods give confidence
Your writing methods have given me the self-confidence to successfully teach
even the most reluctant writers.
~ Christine
Strategic planning device that beats outlining
Experienced nonfiction writers might be able to keep their thesis
clearly in mind without having it physically attached to their outlines,
but novice writers would struggle to do so.
That problem led me to develop a strategic outlining device I
call a writing skeleton that keeps the outline tied to the
working thesis. Learn more here.