Students can't create outline But they can craft, make,
or do one.
Avoid terms like create outline if you want your students
to plan their writing before they start writing. Many students
hear the word outline in the same sentence as create
and panic at what experience has led them to believe will be difficult
and frustrating work.
Watch your terms and do no harm
Use language that makes preparing an essay outline or research
paper outline sound like something that can be done at the kitchen
table or garage workbench. Josh can make an outline, Sean
can construct an outline Caitlin can craft an outline,
and Tiffany can do an outline and all of them can make
plans.
I never cease to marvel at how most of my college students' distaste
for writing disappears when they learn they will not be required
to do any creative writing in my classes.
In teaching writing, getting students past their reluctance to
attempt basic writing tasks is the first step toward making them
into competent writers. Sometimes the easiest way to overcome fears
and negative responses is to avoid using terms associated with
those negative feelings toward writing, words such as create
outline.
Language shapes behavior
Josh, Sean, Caitlin, and Tiffany aren't the only people whose
behaviors are shaped by language. Consider, for example:
Preowned vehicles are more desirable transportation than used
cars.
Designer dog breeds are far more desirable pets than mutts.
When governments don't want to donate to antipoverty programs,
they say the proposed recipients suffer from food insecurity.
When they want to be seen doing good, those governments give
to people who are starving.
As you are teaching writing, look for ways to:
Use language to overcome reluctance to engage in writing activities,
such as by substituting other terms for the phrase create
an outline.
Cultivate students' awareness of how language shapes behavior.
Language matters. What better place to teach that to students than
while you are teaching writing?
Teaching writing is like writing
Teaching writing is a lot like learning to write.
You don't need to know much at the start, but you must be willing to learn.
You must work consistently to improve and tolerate failures as you learn.
Above all, you have to accept the fact that everyone thinks what you do
is easy except the people who do it every day.